Which golf scoring format should you play?
Stroke play counts every shot and suits serious competition; match play scores hole by hole and suits two players or pairs; Stableford caps the damage on any hole and suits mixed-ability groups; skins puts a prize on each hole and suits a casual fourball. The right choice mostly depends on how wide the handicap spread in your group is.
The four, at a glance
| Format | How it is scored | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Stroke play | Total shots across the round | Serious competition, similar handicaps |
| Match play | Holes won, lost or halved | Two players or two pairs |
| Stableford | Points per hole against net par | Mixed abilities, society days |
| Skins | A prize on each hole, outright wins only | A casual fourball |
The Caddy scores all four, and applies handicap strokes in each of them from the card’s stroke index.
Stroke play
Every shot counts and the lowest total wins. It is the purest measure and the least forgiving — a single hole can end a round, and there is no mechanism that stops it.
It works when the group is of a similar standard and everybody intends to finish. It works badly as a format for a mixed society day, where one player is out of it by the fourth hole.
Match play
The round becomes eighteen separate contests. Win a hole and you go one up; the score is a running difference rather than a total, so a nine on one hole costs you exactly one hole.
Handicap strokes are applied on the *difference* between the players rather than in full — an 18 against a 10 receives eight strokes, on stroke index 1 to 8. That detail is the one most often got wrong in a casual match.
Stableford
Points against net par on each hole, with nothing scored for a net double bogey or worse. Because a bad hole is capped at zero, players can pick up and the group keeps moving.
It is the format that best absorbs a wide spread of abilities, which is why almost every club competition and society day uses it.
Skins
Each hole carries a prize, won only outright. Tie the hole and the prize carries forward, so the pot builds until somebody wins a hole cleanly.
The carry-over is what makes it work socially: a player having a poor round can still take a large pot on the sixteenth, so nobody is out of it. It is a format for a fourball rather than a competition.
Choosing
The deciding factor is usually the handicap spread. Narrow spread and a competitive mood points to stroke play or match play; wide spread points to Stableford or skins.
The second factor is pace. Any format allowing a pick-up — Stableford and skins both do — will get a slow fourball round noticeably faster.
Common questions
Which format is best for a society day?
Stableford, in almost every case. It handles a wide spread of handicaps, caps the damage on any hole, and lets players pick up, which keeps the field moving.
How are handicaps applied in match play?
On the difference between the two handicaps, not in full. The lower handicap plays off scratch and the higher receives the difference, allocated from stroke index 1 upwards.
What happens when a skins hole is tied?
The prize carries over to the next hole, so the pot grows until a hole is won outright.
KEEP READING
Download for FREE today
